Please note: this meeting's minutes have not been finalized yet. Actions taken on legislation and their results are not available.
Meeting Name: Planning Commission Agenda status: Final
Meeting date/time: 5/5/2022 6:00 PM Minutes status: Draft  
Meeting location: 825 Fifth Street Board of Supervisors Chambers Eureka, California
Regular Meeting - Hybrid
Published agenda: Agenda (PDF) Agenda (PDF) Published minutes: Action Summary Action Summary  
Meeting video:  
Attachments: Public Comment - Brenda Vait - Humboldt fair events.pdf, Public Comment - Graham and Kristen Westfall - Humboldt County Fairgrounds 17561.pdf, Public Comment - Janet Carney - Planning Dept. letter 4-28-22 17561 HCFA.pdf, Public Comment - Jennifer Raymond - 4-20-22 Letter re HC Fair Grounds PLN-2022-17561.pdf, Public Comment - Joyce Coppini - Humboldt County Fair Association, Ferndale area, case Number PLN -2, Public Comment - Skip Jorgensen - Fairgrounds.pdf, Public Comment - Phillip Ostler - In Support.pdf, Public Comment - Annonymous -11212 MDRV Realty.pdf, Public Comment - Bayside Community Hall - Old Arcata Road.pdf, Public Comment - Sue Moore - Old Arcata Road Project_ County and Board of Supervisors' Hearings.pdf, Public Comment - Bonnie Blackberry - 3-3-22 PC comments re Blocksburg.pdf, Public Comment - Holder Law Group - Letter to PC and Dir Ford re Blocksburg Family Farm Project w Ex, Public Comment - Karen Fenton - submittal for PLN-2020-16475, APN 205-231-029.pdf, Public Comment - Rick Levos - Organic Humboldt PLN-2020-16475 APN 205-231-029.pdf, Public Comment - Robert Brock - Organic Humboldt LLC PLN-2020-16475 205-231-029.pdf, Public Comment - Carolyn Jones - RE_ Old Arcata Road Rehab Project Roundabout Design.pdf, Public Comment - Jill Dedini - Old Arcata Road Project.pdf, Public Comment - Mistwood Educational Center - Arcata roundabout.pdf, Public Comment - Sue Moore - Old Arcata Road hearing.pdf, Public Comment - Carolyn Jones - RE_ Old Arcata Road Rehab Project Roundabout Design.pdf, Public Comment - Chris Johnson Hamer - arcata road.pdf, Public Comment - Greg Nesty - Proposed roundabout.pdf, Public Comment - Jill Dedini - Old Arcata Road Project.pdf, Public Comment - Jim Moore - 17654 Old Arcata Road.pdf, Public Comment - Jim Zoellick - OldArcataRdProject-Zoellick_220426.pdf, Public Comment - Mistwood Educational Center - Arcata roundabout.pdf, Public Comment - Nicole Frank - 4.26.22 Roundabout Support Letter.pdf, Public Comment - Robert McPherson - Upcoming CDP Permit 17654.pdf, Public Comment - Sue Moore - Old Arcata Road hearing.pdf, Public Comment - Arne Petersen - Supplemental MND Response.pdf, Public Comment - Jessica Bones - Organic Humboldt LLC. PLN-2020-16475 apn 205-231-029.pdf, Public Comment - Johanna Rodoni - 445 Stafford Road.pdf, Public Comment - Sue Moore - Old Arcata Road Project Hearing_ CDP.pdf, Public Comment - Indy Riggs - Organic Humboldt, LLC, PLN-2020-16475, APN 205-231-029.pdf, Public Comment - John Emig - Fairgrounds Motorcycle Racing PLN-2022-17561.pdf, Public Comment - Stephen Avis, AICP and Jennifer Raymond - HCFA 42922 comment letter.pdf, Public Comment - Allen Swank - Nava Ranch Complaint.pdf, Public Comment - Fenton - additional argument against Organic Humboldt.pdf, Public Comment - Lee Dedini - Specific questions to project,.pdf, Public Comment - Marc Delany - Arcata roundabout - What they knew then how they play it no.pdf, Public Comment - Michael Everson - PLN–2021–17162-Nova Ranch.pdf, Public Comment - Nicholas Ghirelli - Letter on Supplemental MND.pdf, Public Comment - Claire Trower - PLN 2021-17162 Nava ranch expansion.pdf, Public Comment - County Response_Final_PLN_2021-17162 Nova Ranch.pdf, Public Comment - Gary Haga and LaDonna Landergen-Haga - Updated Nava Ranch Concerns.pdf, Public Comment - Haga - Letter Regarding Nava Ranch_17162.pdf, Public Comment - Linda Franklin - FW_ Expansion PLN 2021-17162.pdf, Public Comment - Maureen Catalina - PLN 2021-17162 Nava ranch expansion 2.pdf, Public Comment - Maureen Catalina - PLN 2021-17162 Nava ranch expansion.pdf, Public Comment - Robie Tenorio - Nava 171662 Comments.pdf, Public Comment - Jason Holder - Follow Up Letter to PC re Blocksburg Family Farm 042022.pdf, Public Comment - Carla Paliaga - Re_ Support for OAR Improvement Project.pdf, Public Comment - Gwelen Paliaga - Comments Regarding Old Arcata Rd. Improvement Project.pdf, Public Comment - Robie Tenorio - Nava 17162 Comments.pdf, Public Comment - Jude Power - letter to county planning commission 422.pdf, Public Comment - Kiriki Delany - Affected Property Owner Public Comment Old Arcata Road.pdf, Public Comment - James Zoellick - Old Arcata Road Improvement Project.pdf, Public Comment - Jim Stretch Sr. - HCFA.pdf, Public Comment - Chris Hamer - Comment Letter re Old Arcata Road Public Safety to the HC Planning Co, Public Comment - Chris Hamer - Comment Letter re Old Arcata RoadConflict of Interest to the HC Plann, Public Comment - Chris Hamer - Comment Letter re Old Arcata RoadHistoric Resources to the HC Plannin, Public Comment - Chris Hamer - Comment Letter re Old Arcata RoadWetlands to the HC Planning Commissi, Public Comment - Gordon Inkeles - Old Arcata Road renewal project.pdf, Public Comment - Jenny Auwarter - FINAL Attachment 1 to Letter to City re FEIR Old Arcata Road.pdf, Public Comment - Michael Love - Support for the Old Arcata Road Project.pdf, Supplemental 17654 City of Arcata, Public Comment - David Buxbaum - Comments for Record Number PLN-2020-16621 hearing on May 5, 2022.pd, Public Comment - Iris Schencke - Old Arcata Road Improvement Project -.pdf, Public Comment - Jason Holder - CSH and NEC Further Follow Up Letter to PC re Blocksburg Family Farm, Public Comment - Linda Palmrose - Old Arcata Road.pdf, Public Comment - Maureen Catalina - Nava Ranch.pdf, Public Comment - Michael Dehority - Old Arcata Road.pdf, Public Comment - Roxy Kennedy - Mezzrow Farms, Record Number PLN 2020-16621.pdf, Public Comment - Roxy Kennedy - Please do not approve Nava Ranch Expansion.pdf, Public Comment - Roxy Kennedy - Re_ Please do not approve Nava Ranch nor Mezzrow Farms Expansions.pd, Public Comment - Sara Dronkers - 5_5 Planning Commission consideration of Old Arcata Road Improvemen, Public Comment - Aaron Hohl - Old Arcata Road.pdf, Public Comment - Bert Colbert - Old Arcata Road Project.pdf, Public Comment - Greta Montagne - City of Arcata.pdf, Public Comment - Jane Minor - Old Arcata Road Project.pdf, Public Comment - Jill Dedini - Old Arcata Road Project.pdf, Public Comment - Jude Power - Old Arcata Road Project.pdf, Public Comment - Lee Dedini - Old Arcata Road.pdf, Public Comment - Michael Minor - Old Arcata Road.pdf, Public Comment - Clara Sander - Oar roundabout.pdf, Public Comment - Dan Wooden - Re_Complaint re_ Nava Ranch PLN-2021-17162, APN# 107-106-006.pdf, Public Comment - Kathleen Stanton - Deny Approval of a Coastal Development Permit due to significant, Public Comment - Lee Dedini - Fwd_ Old Arcata Road Rehabilitation and Pedestrian_Bikeway Improvement, Public Comment - Michael Minor - Fwd_ Old Arcata Road Improvement Project.pdf, Supplemental 12265 Blocksburg, Public Comment - Steve McDonald - Fw_ Support for Old Arcata Road Roundabout at Jacoby Creek Road.pd
File #Ver.Agenda #NameTypeTitleActionResultAction DetailsVideo
11219 12. Zoning ItemNikolai Erickson; Conditional Use Permit Record Number PLN-11219-CUP (filed 09/23/2016) Assessor’s Parcel Number (APN) 208-201-020 Dinsmore area A Conditional Use Permit for 22,649 square feet of pre-existing outdoor cannabis cultivation, and 2,200 square feet of ancillary propagation. Water for irrigation is provided by rain catchment from rooftops of three existing structures on-site. The applicant anticipates using 100,000 gallons of water per year (4.02 gal/sq.ft./yr.), and the applicant utilizes several water conservation methods on-site. A total of 160,000 gallons of water storage exists on-site in thirty-six hard sided tanks. Processing at the site includes drying and curing, and trimming will occur off-site at a licensed processing facility. There will be 2 employees on site for cultivation activities. Power is provided by two portable generators and will transition to full renewable energy sources by 2026. The Humboldt County Planning Commission will consider an Addendum to a previously adopted MND and has been prepared for consideration per §15164 of the State CEQA Guideli   Not available Video Video
12457 13. Zoning ItemLove and Laughter Farms; Special Permit Record Number PLN-12457-SP (filed 12/23/2016) Assessor’s Parcel Number (APN) 522-941-001 Hoopa area The applicant is seeking a Special Permit for 10,000 square feet of existing full-sun outdoor commercial cannabis cultivation. One harvest is obtained annually. Water for irrigation was historically sourced from a registered spring diversion from Pine Creek, however, the applicant is transitioning to entirely rainwater catchment. The applicants projected annual water usage is 37,500 gallons. Water storage onsite totals 37,500 gallons. Processing such as drying and curing occurs onsite in an existing 770 square foot structure, further processing occurs offsite at a licensed third-party processing facility. The project is owner operated; therefore, no employees are required. The minimal energy required for the project is sourced from a generator however alternative energy will be required. The Humboldt County Planning Commission will consider an Addendum to a previously adopted Mitigated Negative Declaration and has been prepared for consideratio   Not available Video Video
17254 14. Zoning ItemHumboldt IQ, LLC; Conditional Use Permit Record Number PLN-2021-17254 (filed 05/26/2021) Assessor’s Parcel Number (APN) 201-322-011 Fortuna area Conditional Use Permits for commercial cannabis distribution and off-site processing in the Fortuna Community Planning Area. The annual water budget of 72,000 gallons is provided exclusively by rainwater catchment supported by 35,000 gallons of storage. Power is sourced from PGE through an eligible renewable energy program. There will be 10 employees at peak operations. The Conditional Use Permits include allowing the proposed uses in the Qualified (Q) zone. The Humboldt County Planning Commission will consider an Addendum to a previously adopted EIR and has been prepared for consideration per §15164 of the State CEQA Guidelines.   Not available Video Video
16475 15. Zoning ItemOrganic Humboldt, LLC: Special Permit and Zoning Clearance Certificate Record Number PLN-2020-16475 (filed 06/26/2020) Assessor’s Parcel Number: 205-231-029 Scotia area The applicant is seeking a Special Permit for 43,560 square feet of new outdoor commercial cannabis cultivation and a Zoning Clearance Certificate for 13,500 square feet of existing outdoor cultivation being relocated to the subject parcel under the RRR program. Total cultivation on the parcel totals 57,060 square feet of outdoor commercial cannabis cultivation. Light depravation techniques may be utilized to achieve two harvests annually. The project will be supported by 5,706 square feet of propagation space. The applicant will implement dry farming practices, although supplemental irrigation water will be sourced from the existing rainwater catchment system. The projected annual water usage is estimated to be 20,000 gallons and the existing water storage totals 50,000 gallons. All processing will occur offsite at a licensed third-party processing facility. Energy for the operation will be supplied by the exis   Not available Video Video
17561 16. Zoning ItemHumboldt County Fair Association: Modification to Conditional Use Permit Case Number PLN-2022-17561 (filed 12/29/2021) Assessor Parcel Numbers (APNs) 030-071-001, 030-011-003, 030-021-003, 030-112-017, 030-112-020, 030-081-006, and 100-181-003 Ferndale area Humboldt County Fair Association (HCFA) is seeking to modify a Conditional Use Permit which authorizes five (5) concerts and two (2) motorcycle racing events to be held each year at the Humboldt County Fairgrounds. The approved permit places limitations on event-related noise levels, including a 63-decibel limit on composite noise measured by averaging noise readings collected during a 24-hour period surrounding each event, as well as a 90-decibel instantaneous noise limit applied to all motorcycles participating in racing events. In their modification request, HCFA is seeking authorization to raise the 90-decibel motorcycle noise limit to 99 decibels to be consistent with common national testing standards for competition established by the American Motorcyclist Association (AMA). Analysis of the proposal’s effect on compo   Not available Video Video
17162 11. Zoning ItemNava Ranch, LLC: Special Permit Record Number PLN-2021-17162 (filed 4/15/2021) Assessor’s Parcel Number (APN) 107-106-006 Honeydew area A Special Permit for the expansion of an approved cultivation site (PLN-12657-SP). The project will consist of 43,560 square feet (SF) of mixed light cultivation in twelve (12) greenhouses and 2,500 SF of indoor cultivation in a converted barn. The original project consisted of 6,600 square feet of mixed light cultivation, 2,700 square feet of outdoor cultivation, and 2,500 square feet of indoor cultivation. The outdoor cultivation will be converted to mixed light and the total mixed light cultivation area will be expanded to one acre. This represents a total increase of 34,260 SF of cultivation area. The applicant hopes to achieve up to three (3) harvests annually. All water will be sourced by rainwater catchment from an existing pond, a proposed pond, and an existing rooftop rainwater catchment system. The estimated water needed annually for irrigation is approximately 550,000 gallons (11.94 gal/sq.ft./yr). Please note that this estimate may   Not available Video Video
17162 11. Zoning ItemNava Ranch, LLC: Special Permit Record Number PLN-2021-17162 (filed 4/15/2021) Assessor’s Parcel Number (APN) 107-106-006 Honeydew area A Special Permit for the expansion of an approved cultivation site (PLN-12657-SP). The project will consist of 43,560 square feet (SF) of mixed light cultivation in twelve (12) greenhouses and 2,500 SF of indoor cultivation in a converted barn. The original project consisted of 6,600 square feet of mixed light cultivation, 2,700 square feet of outdoor cultivation, and 2,500 square feet of indoor cultivation. The outdoor cultivation will be converted to mixed light and the total mixed light cultivation area will be expanded to one acre. This represents a total increase of 34,260 SF of cultivation area. The applicant hopes to achieve up to three (3) harvests annually. All water will be sourced by rainwater catchment from an existing pond, a proposed pond, and an existing rooftop rainwater catchment system. The estimated water needed annually for irrigation is approximately 550,000 gallons (11.94 gal/sq.ft./yr). Please note that this estimate may   Not available Video Video
17162 11. Zoning ItemNava Ranch, LLC: Special Permit Record Number PLN-2021-17162 (filed 4/15/2021) Assessor’s Parcel Number (APN) 107-106-006 Honeydew area A Special Permit for the expansion of an approved cultivation site (PLN-12657-SP). The project will consist of 43,560 square feet (SF) of mixed light cultivation in twelve (12) greenhouses and 2,500 SF of indoor cultivation in a converted barn. The original project consisted of 6,600 square feet of mixed light cultivation, 2,700 square feet of outdoor cultivation, and 2,500 square feet of indoor cultivation. The outdoor cultivation will be converted to mixed light and the total mixed light cultivation area will be expanded to one acre. This represents a total increase of 34,260 SF of cultivation area. The applicant hopes to achieve up to three (3) harvests annually. All water will be sourced by rainwater catchment from an existing pond, a proposed pond, and an existing rooftop rainwater catchment system. The estimated water needed annually for irrigation is approximately 550,000 gallons (11.94 gal/sq.ft./yr). Please note that this estimate may   Not available Video Video
12265 12. Zoning ItemBlocksburg Family Farm, LLC: Conditional Use Permit Record Number: PLN-12265-CUP (filed 12/22/2016) Assessor’s Parcel Number (APN): 217-471-001 Blocksburg area A Conditional Use Permit for 6.39 acres of outdoor cultivation including 16,800 sf of existing cannabis authorized under interim permit, on a parcel of approximately 1,221 acres. The proposed six acres of new will comprise of three acres full term outdoor and three acres of Light Deprivation, and with ancillary facilities, will be developed in four phases over four years. Water would be provided by an onsite well, a 2.2-million-gallon rain catchment pond, and a one-million-gallon rainwater catchment tank. Total irrigation demand by Phase IV is anticipated to be approximately 3.1 million gallons per year, with the rain catchment pond being the primary source of water by Phases II and III. The project includes 8,000 sf of proposed and 2,000 sf of existing ancillary nursery space. Processing would occur onsite in a proposed 7,200 sf multi-use building in the footprint of a burned down barn. Power is proposed to be provided    Not available Video Video
17654 13. Zoning ItemOld Arcata Road Rehabilitation and Pedestrian/Bikeway Improvements Coastal Development Permit Record Number PLN-2022-17654 (filed 02/28/2022) Assessor’s Parcel Number: County right-of-way does not have APNs. Adjacent APNs include but not limited to 501-012-012, 501-031-032, 501-011-006, and 501-031-031. Bayside area A Coastal Development Permit (CDP) for the small portion of the project that is located within the County’s jurisdiction of the Coastal Zone. The project would improve motorized and non-motorized transportation and user safety in Bayside. The Project would repave Old Arcata Road, include bike lanes on both sides of the roadway alignment, and improve and extend an existing shared use walkway along the west side of Old Arcata Road from approximately 600 feet south of the Buttermilk Road Roundabout and extending south to approximately 300 feet beyond the Jacoby Creek Road intersection. The total Project length is approximately one mile. The portion of the project within both the Coastal Zone and the County’s jurisdiction is located at the southern end of the project,    Not available Video Video
14376 14. Zoning ItemPG&E After-the-fact Coastal Development Permit Record Number PLN-14376-CDP (filed 09/24/2020) Adjacent to Assessor’s Parcel Number (APN) 517-041-016 Trinidad Area An after-the-fact Coastal Development Permit which includes modification of an existing electric distribution facility previously constructed without permits. Proposed modifications to the facility consist of the following: removal of one 45-foot-tall utility pole, replacement of two 45-foot-tall utility poles with 55-foot-tall poles, installation of a new 55-foot-tall pole and 3 platform mounted voltage regulators. The poles were installed within the County right-of-way and near the driveway that serves parcel 517-041-016. An existing utility pole is located 8-feet south of the existing driveway and will remain in place. The design standards for allowable pole sizes for platform mounted voltage regulators has changed to a 55-foot-tall pole, while the previous standards allowed for a 45-foot-tall pole, driving the need for the height increase of the existing facility. PG&E is proposing to install three (3) 55-foot-ta   Not available Not available
11212 11. Zoning ItemMDRV Realty Holdings, LLC; Conditional Use Permit & Special Permits Record Numbers PLN-11212-CUP and PLN-11214-SP (filed 9/22/2016) Assessor’s Parcel Numbers (APNs) 208-241-007 and 208-241-006 Dinsmore/Mad River area Two separate applications owned and currently operated by the same party. The first is a Conditional Use Permit for 14,450 sf of existing outdoor & 3,600 sf of existing mixed-light cannabis cultivation with 1,480 sf of ancillary propagation area. The proposed project includes a Special Permit for the relocation of a historic cultivation outside of a streamside management area. Water for irrigation is provided by an on-site spring diversion (POD 2 under Water Right Certificate H100730), and a Special Permit is being requested to approve the continued use and maintenance of the spring diversion. Annual water usage is estimated at 150,000 gallons (7.68 gal/sf/yr). There is a total of 110,000 gallons of existing water storage on-site and 63,000 additional water storage is proposed for a total of 173,000 gallons. Drying and curing will occur on-site and trimming will occur o   Not available Video Video